Becoming a DIY (Do-It-Yourself) landlord can be an enriching experience, offering the potential for financial gains, personal satisfaction from property management, and the opportunity to meet and interact with a variety of tenants.

However, the path of a DIY landlord is fraught with potential pitfalls that can turn what should be a rewarding endeavor into a costly and stressful affair. 

Here are the critical mistakes to avoid as you embark on your journey as a DIY landlord:

1. Neglecting Legal Requirements and Regulations

One of the most critical errors DIY landlords make is overlooking the legal aspects of renting out property. Each country, state, and even city can have its unique set of housing laws and regulations, including tenant rights, eviction procedures, safety codes, and licensing requirements.

Failing to comply with these laws can result in hefty fines, legal disputes, and significant financial losses. To prevent this, invest time in understanding the specific landlord-tenant laws applicable to your area.

Consider consulting a real estate attorney to ensure your lease agreements, eviction notices, and property standards comply with local, state, and federal laws.

2. Inadequate Tenant Screening

Another common mistake is not thoroughly vetting potential tenants. A bad tenant can cause numerous problems, from unpaid rent to property damage and legal issues.


Make sure to implement a comprehensive tenant screening process that includes credit checks, employment verification, rental history, and criminal background checks. Be consistent and fair in your screening process to avoid accusations of discrimination.

3. Underestimating Maintenance Costs and Responsibilities

Many new DIY landlords fail to account for the ongoing maintenance costs and the effort required to keep a property in good condition. Neglecting property maintenance can lead to higher repair costs down the line and dissatisfied tenants.

You have to set aside a portion of your rental income for regular maintenance and emergency repairs. Establish a network of reliable contractors you can call on when repairs or renovations are beyond your DIY skills.

4. Poor Financial Management

Effective financial management is crucial for the success of your venture as a DIY landlord. This includes not only tracking rental income and expenses but also understanding the tax implications of your rental property.

It’s best to use property management software or hire an accountant to keep your finances in order. Educate yourself about the tax benefits and obligations related to your rental property, such as deductions for maintenance, improvements, and depreciation.

5. Ignoring the Importance of a Comprehensive Lease Agreement

A lease agreement is not just a formality; it’s a critical document that outlines the rights and responsibilities of both the landlord and the tenant. An incomplete or vague lease can lead to misunderstandings and legal disputes.


To avoid this, ensure your lease agreement is comprehensive and clearly outlines policies on rent, security deposits, pet policies, maintenance responsibilities, and termination procedures. Consider having your lease reviewed by a lawyer.

6. Failing to Communicate Effectively with Tenants

Good communication is the backbone of a positive landlord-tenant relationship. Failure to communicate clearly, promptly, and professionally can lead to misunderstandings and erode trust.

Avoid this by establishing clear channels of communication with your tenants. Be proactive in addressing concerns and responsive to requests. Regularly check in with your tenants to ensure their satisfaction and to address any potential issues before they escalate.

7. Not Having Proper Insurance

Many DIY landlords underestimate the importance of having the right insurance coverage. Standard homeowners’ insurance may not cover all the risks associated with renting out your property.

Make sure to review your insurance policy to ensure it covers rental activities. Consider additional coverage such as landlord liability insurance and loss of rental income insurance to protect yourself against unforeseen events.

8. Overlooking Property Inspections

Regular property inspections are crucial to identify maintenance issues before they become serious problems. Skipping inspections can lead to expensive repairs and tenant complaints.

You have to conduct regular inspections of your property, with proper notice to your tenants, to ensure the property is well-maintained and to address any issues promptly.

9. Handling Evictions Improperly

Evictions are an unpleasant but sometimes necessary part of being a landlord. Mishandling an eviction can lead to legal challenges and further complications.


You need to familiarize yourself with the legal eviction process in your jurisdiction and follow it to the letter. Consider hiring a lawyer to assist with the eviction to ensure it’s done legally and professionally.

Why It’s Best to Work With a Professional Property Management Company

Working with a professional property management company can provide numerous advantages for landlords, especially those who are new to the rental market, have multiple properties, or simply do not have the time or expertise to manage properties effectively on their own. 

Comprehensive Rental Market Expertise

Professional property managers offer extensive knowledge of local rental markets, covering pricing trends, tenant preferences, and effective marketing strategies. With this expertise, your property is competitively priced, marketed efficiently, and quickly occupied, minimizing vacancies and maximizing income. 

Property managers are also well-versed in rental laws, including landlord-tenant regulations and fair housing laws, ensuring compliance and minimizing legal risks for landlords.

Comprehensive Tenant Screening Processes

A property management company typically has stringent tenant screening processes in place, which can include credit checks, criminal background checks, employment verification, and previous rental history.

This thorough vetting helps in finding reliable tenants, reducing the likelihood of rent defaults, property damage, and other tenant-related issues.

Efficient Rent Collection and Financial Management

Rent collection and financial management are critical aspects of property management that can become challenging for DIY landlords. 


Property management companies have systems and processes to ensure timely rent collection and handle any delinquencies effectively. They also manage financial records, providing landlords with regular financial reports and statements for easier tracking and tax preparation.

Maintenance and Repair Coordination

One of the most significant benefits of working with a property management company is their ability to handle all aspects of property maintenance and repairs.

They often have a network of trusted contractors and vendors to ensure that maintenance issues are addressed promptly and cost-effectively, keeping tenants happy and preserving the value of your property.

Enhanced Tenant Satisfaction and Time Efficiency

Professional property managers excel in tenant satisfaction and retention by promptly addressing concerns, maintaining properties, and nurturing positive landlord-tenant rapport. This not only boosts retention rates but also slashes turnover costs. 

Landlords can benefit from significant time savings and stress reduction as property management companies handle emergencies, complaints, and legal matters efficiently, enabling them to concentrate on other endeavors.


Being a DIY landlord comes with its set of challenges, but by avoiding these common mistakes, you can minimize risks and maximize the rewards of your rental property investment. However, it’s best to work with a professional property management company like Keyrenter Austin to ensure that these mistakes will never happen. 

Contact Keyrenter Austin today if you need help, and we’ll be happy to help you!